165 share
Published 12/3/2012
The GOP proposal increases the age limit on Medicare from 65 to 67 - saving $600 billion dollars in that very simple solution. It would cut the rate of yearly increase to Social Security to a percentage of inflation, rather than using the inflation rate, itself. It would supply $800 billion in new revenues via eliminating deductions given to the uber rich. It would borrow $4 trillion less than the current debt increase - all this over a period of the next ten years. Much of the GOP plan borrows from the Bowles/Simpson plan, a committee commissioned by Obama nearly two years ago. You can compare these notes with the summary at the Washington
Post.
The plan was submitted to the WH earlier in the day. It did not take two hours for Obama to dismiss the GOP plan, out of hand. "No balance" was the presidential complaint, as if his plan came anywhere close to a balanced proposal.
In stead of beginning negotiations in closed door sessions, as has every other congress in the history of this country -- every other congress, without exception, Obama has ended the negotiation process or so it appears.
Here is Speaker Boehner's letter/budget to Obama.
December 3, 2012
The President
The White House
1600 Pennsylvania Avenue, Northwest
Washington, DC 20500
Dear Mr. President,
After a status quo election in which both you and the Republican
majority in the House were re-elected, the American people rightly
expect both parties to come together on a fair middle ground and address
the nation’s most pressing challenges.
To that end, shortly after the election, we presented you with a
balanced framework for averting the fiscal cliff by coupling spending
cuts and reforms with new tax revenue. We then welcomed Secretary
Geithner to the Capitol on November 29 with every expectation that he
would lay out a similarly reasonable path.
Regrettably, the proposal he outlined on behalf of your
Administration contains very little in the way of common ground. The
proposal calls for $1.6 trillion in new tax revenue, twice the amount
you supported during the campaign. The proposal also includes four
times as much tax revenue as spending cuts, in stark contrast to the
“balanced approach” on which you campaigned. While administration
officials are claiming that this proposal contains 2.5 dollars of
spending cuts for each dollar in new revenue, counting as part of this
ratio previously enacted savings – as if these were new spending
reductions – only confuses the public debate. What’s worse, the modest
spending cuts in this offer are cancelled out by the additional
‘stimulus’ measures the Administration is requesting. And, this
proposal would remove any and all limits on federal borrowing.
We cannot in good conscience agree to this approach, which is neither
balanced nor realistic. If we were to take your Administration’s
proposal at face value, then we would counter with the House-passed
Budget Resolution. It assumes an overhaul of our tax code with revenue
remaining at historically normal levels and proposes structural reforms
to preserve and protect the Nation's entitlement programs, ensuring they
are sustainable for the long-term rather than continuing to grow out of
control. Some of its key reforms include:
- The House-passed Budget Resolution assumes enactment of
structural Medicare reform that offers future beneficiaries guaranteed
coverage options, including a traditional fee-for-service Medicare
plan. This proposal is based on recent bipartisan efforts and would
provide greater support for the poor and the sick and less support for
the wealthy. We achieve these reforms in Medicare without affecting
current seniors or those nearing retirement. This would slow the
projected explosive spending growth in this program and eventually
maintain Medicare spending as a share of the economy at 4.75 percent,
thus saving the program for future generations.
- The House-passed Budget Resolution reforms Medicaid and provides
states with greater flexibility to better deliver health security to
beneficiaries, saving the federal government nearly $800 billion over 10
years.
- Separate from savings in our proposal for the 2010 health care law,
the House-passed Budget Resolution envisions hundreds of billions in
savings in other mandatory spending, including reforms to Federal
employee compensation and the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program.
These reforms are, in our view, absolutely essential to
addressing the true drivers of our debt, and we will continue to support
and advance them. At the same time, mindful of the status quo election
and past exchanges on these questions, we recognize it would be
counterproductive to publicly or privately propose entitlement reforms
that you and the leaders of your party appear unwilling to support in
the near-term.
With the fiscal cliff nearing, our priority remains finding a
reasonable solution that can pass both the House and the Senate, and be
signed into law in the next couple of weeks. The best way to do this is
by learning from and building on the bipartisan discussions that have
occurred during this Congress, including the Biden Group, the Joint
Select Committee, and our negotiations leading up to the Budget Control
Act.
For instance, on November 1 of last year, Erskine Bowles, the
co-chair of your debt commission, presented the Joint Select Committee
with a middle ground approach that garnered praise from many fiscal
watchdogs and nonpartisan experts. He recommended that both parties
agree to a balanced package that includes significant spending cuts as
well as $800 billion in new revenue.
Notably, the new revenue in the Bowles plan would not be achieved
through higher tax rates, which we continue to oppose and will not agree
to in order to protect small businesses and our economy. Instead, new
revenue would be generated through pro-growth tax reform that closes
special-interest loopholes and deductions while lowering rates. On the
spending side, the Bowles recommendation would cut more than $900
billion in mandatory spending and another $300 billion in discretionary
spending. These cuts would be over and above the spending reductions
enacted in the
Budget Control Act.
This is by no means an adequate long-term solution, as resolving our
long-term fiscal crisis will require fundamental entitlement reform.
Indeed, the Bowles plan is exactly the kind of imperfect, but fair
middle ground that allows us to avert the fiscal cliff without hurting
our economy and destroying jobs. We believe it warrants immediate
consideration.
If you are agreeable to this framework, we are ready and eager to
begin discussions about how to structure these reforms so that the
American people can be confident that these targets will be reached.
Again, the American people expect their leaders to find fair middle
ground to address the nation’s most pressing challenges. To achieve
that outcome, we respectfully request that you respond to this letter in
a timely fashion and hope that you will refrain from any further action
that would undermine good-faith efforts to reach a reasonable and
equitable agreement in this critical matter.
Sincerely,
John Boehner, Speaker
Eric Cantor, Majority Leader
Kevin McCarthy, Majority Whip
Cathy McMorris Rodgers, Republican Conference Chairman
Dave Camp, Chairman, Committee on Ways and Means
Paul Ryan, Committee on the Budget
Fred Upton, Committee on Energy & Commerce
http://www.speaker.gov/press-release/house-gop-leaders-make-new-offer-avert-fiscal-cliff